Man climbing broken ladder out of angry crowd

The Illusion of Upward Mobility

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email

There is something that’s been eating me inside and out and I have not been able to articulate this until now, but I am gonna try because I think it is very important. At least to me it is.

The sickness of our neoliberal world impacts both the middle class and the poor.

When you see generational poverty, it is easy to see it outright. It’s extreme. It’s often hopeless to the individual. It’s bleak and the political space uses poverty as a political tool. One for explaining “bad choices” and one that exploits it as “immoral”. But it’s a veneer.

It’s used as a political football. Two angles: you are a bad person and undeserving or my goodness this is so tragic we must save you with a pittance… Charity … Hand outs… No structural change… No real change.

But then we have the middle class angle. Everyone is gonna do great if we just give them a new program to take a real problem and make it a little less daunting. A pittance. No structural changes but we discipline labor with taxes and precarity and enticements to become rich…

So we lure the middle class and poor and dangle college or the military respectively as a way out and up.
We burden the middle class with lots of pay ins. Lots of debt. Lots of impossible debt… Because once you start the path to leave your station… Your birth class… You are expected to pay in to get in.

It starts with expectations on how we dress. How we communicate. The language we use. The cars we drive. The homes we buy and the way we maintain our health. The family pet. Saving for our kids to go to college. The vacations we are expected to go on. The volunteer work we do.

The burden only worsens as we lay the tax burden down. The penalties and the guilt of providing for the family. The overall is a lesson in violence… the path is told in commercials with smiling families with nice clean clothes, washboard abs and perfect teeth.

The problem is when the debt burden comes due… It’s all on you too. You were expected to know how to do this. You were expected to know how to manage money. Lessons many if not most are never taught. I am not talking macroeconomics, I am talking about the personal checkbook. You are expected to be a savvy investor with a portfolio. Never mind divorces from the stress and strain of this ladder climbing.

If the stock market crashes. If your investments collapse. It’s on you and it’s of course rich people problems. If they lie they have family wealth to save them. They have the network to lift them. Or at least the appearance of it…

The very appearance of being well off is a mirage you are expected to maintain.
It gets worse because as you move up the social ladder, bearing all the set and pain you had to bear to get there, you are now expected to be polite and unflappable. To demonstrate no matter how much suicidal stress you are under to maintain the illusion.. that you are polite.

And should the stress and strain be too much, once you get there, you will be rejected as a commoner who still misbehaves. Never mind the expectations and glass ceilings. Never mind that once you “get there” you realize you really aren’t there … You are in a no man’s land where you are still rejected one layer up by the elites and gate keepers of the good life.

You are now an unsympathetic case. You make too much to be seen as “in need” and you are hated by both the rich who want to maintain their exclusive birthrite social circles and the poor who mistake you for rich and the laws which say you don’t need help.

You wake up wondering how you will survive. You are hated by your spouse because you have to kill yourself to maintain a lifestyle you were sold as onward and upward. Your spouse wonders why the neighbors can do this and that but not your family…

So you are expected to do whatever you can to keep the roof on, to smile, to be capable of maintaining this ruse with a smile and politeness.

When the pressure becomes to great… The rafters start looking like a good place to toss a rope…

But yes…politeness is ruled as the currency of the decent. The good. The “right” people… Yet… When you are on top… It’s easy to get a distorted picture of pain and suffering. Elitism is the currency the ladder climbers can never achieve & when they do… Success! Right?

Politeness is the currency those doing well trade in. It is a currency to let you know this is what it looks like when every day is your lucky day. This is the currency that weeds out the class jumpers & those living in the big houses with the elite couture… pets… lifestyles.

It’s the thing we aspire to be like.. to want to be them…

To want to live with a smile, no rotting teeth… No shitty oodles of noodles… No fear of answering the phone. And when you realize you will never belong… And all you worked for crumbles… You die.

Original Tweet thread from @sdgrumbine.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Share this post

Share on facebook
Share on google
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on pinterest
Share on email
Scroll to Top Skip to content